Free U.S. shipping + free returns
Get this mini Blur Stick
free with your $20+ order.
Congratulations
You get a free
mini Blur Stick!

1 / 3

Pale Ale - Light Brown

2 / 3

Pilsner - Medium Brown

3 / 3

Dark Brew - Dark Brown
More Views +

Gel Brow

$18
1 4 5

Matte gel brow pencil for quick application and natural looking brows. Waterproof and transfer-proof, formula defines, accentuates, and stays put all day. Use tip to draw small upward strokes beginning with the inside of the brows, then style and shape with built-in brush. As always, this product is cruelty-free.

Selected color | Pale Ale - Light Brown

Sold Out. Be the first to know when this product is available.

Coming Soon. Be the first to know when this product is available.

Dimethicone, synthetic wax, octyldodecanol, polybutene, cetearyl behenate, disteardimonium hectorite, sorbitan olivate, propylene carbonate, synthetic beeswax, pentaerythrityl tetra-di-t-butyl hydoxyhydrocinnamate, synthetic fluorphlogopite May contain: titanium dioxide, ferric ferrocyanide, iron oxides Pale Ale - Light Brown Dimethicone, synthetic wax, octyldodecanol, polybutene, synthetic fluorphlogopite, cetearyl behenate, disteardimonium hectorite, sorbitan olivate, propylene carbonate, synthetic beeswax, pentaerythrityl tetra-di-t-butyl hydroxyhydrocinnamate, iron oxides, ferric ferrocynanide

Ebony

“It adds some definition to your brows, but still looks natural.”

Shannon

“I thought my brows were too much when I was younger, but now they’re my favorite."

Gender

Overall Review

4
Based on 23 reviews
, Oakland, California
Shade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
great for low maintenance gals!

Love this! I don't pluck or groom my eyebrows, but I wanted something that would give them definition and arch while still looking natural. This did the job! Simple, pigmented, versatile.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (3) | No (0)
, Corvallis, Oregon
Skin Tone | lightSkin Type | normal-dryShade | Pale Ale - Light Brown
Gives me fantastic brows

My brows look really natural and filled in. Great formula, easy to use.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (1) | No (6)
, Gladstone, NJ
Skin Tone | lightSkin Type | normalShade | Pale Ale - Light Brown
Great!

I love this eyebrow pencil! I no longer have to use a gel after I fill in my brows, and Contrary to popular opinion, You actually can sharpen the Pencil! There is a ton of Product! has lasted me over 3 months and still have over half the pencil left!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (7) | No (0)
, Houston, TX
Skin Tone | deepSkin Type | oilyShade | Dark Brew - Dark Brown
Yes Please!

Really like this color. I have black hair but my brows are a little lighter and this color isn't straight black so it looks very natural. I do have to set it with a powder for longevity. Ignore the low reviews, there's plenty of product. This is a pencil that has to be sharpened (You can get one from ... that works great for like $1).

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (9) | No (0)
, Queens, Ny
Skin Tone | mediumSkin Type | normal-dryShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
...

Application was great, easier than taking out my brush and using my ... and it looked very natural... only problem I have is that it does not last as long, which really sucks...

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (4) | No (3)
, Springfield, Missouri
Skin Tone | fairSkin Type | normal-dryShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
Perfect Eye Pencil!

I love this eye pencil. I've never used the gel for my brows, but I was thoroughly impressed. It goes on smoothly and wears all day long. Even with my auburn hair, the pilsner looks legit.

To all the ladies and gents saying there's not enough product: try using an eye pencil sharpener.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (6) | No (0)
, New york, New York
Skin Tone | fairSkin Type | normalShade | Pale Ale - Light Brown
Love this!

Was using a different brand which was discontinued so I tried this one and I LOVE it. It glides on easily and the color pale ale is perfect for me. For the people who are saying you get such a small amount of product...do you guys not realize that you can sharpen the pencil???!!! It's not a twist top. You have to sharpen it!!!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (7) | No (0)
, New Jersey
Skin Tone | lightSkin Type | normalShade | Pale Ale - Light Brown
Love The Brow, Wish It Last Longer

I adore this product! I don't have to use any other gel, or brush to do my brows. The only problem is that there is so little product. I literally used it maybe 5 times and it is out, I was looking everywhere on how to twist like a normal brow pencil, and it doesn't! I love e this product but I am sorely disappointed by the size

Was this review helpful?   Yes (2) | No (17)
, California
Skin Tone | medium-tanSkin Type | normal-dryShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
Took the L

Easy to use and looks great. I have dark black hair (eyebrows included) and it was hard to find a pencil that didn't look too brown. I found that Pilsner worked perfectly for me. However, I noticed a significant amount of eyebrow hair loss after using this product.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (4) | No (6)
, Charleston, South Carolina
Skin Tone | medium-tanSkin Type | sensitiveShade | Dark Brew - Dark Brown
Little Product

I have recently bought the gel brow and it has already run out within a few week time frame. I am really disappointed because of the price of the product, but while it lasted it was working well.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (3) | No (7)
, Orlando, Florida
Skin Tone | medium-tanSkin Type | normalShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
Not worth the money

Has so little product like wtf it's not even that great. I only got like one week use of product on this. 18 dollars for this it's not worth it. No I would never recommend this to anyone at all you can't even twist the pencil to get more product what you see in the picture is what you get.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (5) | No (13)
, Los Angeles, CA
Skin Tone | medium-tanSkin Type | oilyShade | Dark Brew - Dark Brown
Great for filling in sparce areas!

I think the price is perfect for the amount of product. Other popular brow pencils sell for $5 more than this one and have less product. This little thing helps fill in the sparcer areas in my brows and makes them look so natural, but so full! And the spooly is very precise and doesn't catch fuzzies like regular spoolies do. Great product fersure!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (5) | No (0)
, Bainbridge Island, Washington
Shade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
$18

You get very little product when you purchase this eyebrow pencil. Along with that, the spoolie brush is thick and tough, it hurts it use it, at least for me. I do like the product, I just wish I hadn't paid this much for this little. Love the creative names though.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (5) | No (8)
Shade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
too little product :(

I love love love this product, it does wonders for my brows. However, it contains very little product. Although you do get the spoolie with it, I only got about two weeks of daily use out of it, which I think for the price point is a bit unreasonable. Sad because I loved the product so much!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (6) | No (6)
Skin Tone | tanShade | Dark Brew - Dark Brown
Easy to use

I love this brow pencil (I have it in Dark Brew). It's so easy to use, looks very natural, and stays put all day. Prior to getting this, I was never into penciling in my brows. But when I first used this I saw such a big difference that it's now a part of my staple makeup routine in the mornings.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (4) | No (0)
, St. Louis, Missouri
Skin Tone | lightShade | Pale Ale - Light Brown
The perfect natural brow

I got the shade Pale Ale before a trip and was so glad that I did. It is so easy to just put on while you're on the go, also it doesn't looks like it's drawn on. I love the fact that this is gel, it keeps my thick eyebrows in place. I will defiantly be purchasing this again!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (4) | No (0)
, Florida
Skin Tone | fairSkin Type | normal-dryShade | Pale Ale - Light Brown
BEST Eyebrow Pencil

I absolutely love this! It is the perfect shade for my brows and super easy to use. 100% Recommend 👏🏻

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (3) | No (0)
, Elmhurst, IL
Skin Tone | lightSkin Type | normalShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
Natural and beautiful make-up for a cutie that loves to enhance their features

I've always been a fan of gel eye pencils, and when I heard about an eyebrow cosmetic with the same blend ability I was all over it. I have thinner, almost old hollywood style eyebrows, and the idea of bold brows seemed nice. I was worried about that too much "Mommy Dearest" eyebrows, but with product it's only defined brows that look natural.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (1) | No (0)
, Ventura, Ca
Skin Tone | mediumSkin Type | normal-oilyShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
First brow pencil I actually used up

I've had hundreds of brow pencils over the years. Some good, most mediocre.
I tried MILK on a whim and will never buy another brand of pencil.
The formula is creamy, goes on smoothly, looks natural plus the spoolie is at the opposite end for convenience.
If it didn't dwindle so fast when sharpened it would be perfect.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (3) | No (0)
, Boston, MA
Skin Tone | mediumSkin Type | normal-oilyShade | Dark Brew - Dark Brown
New favorite?

Love this product. Easy, comfortable, and provides a natural emphasis on the brow. Very smooth and long-lasting formula, feels more gel-like than any other pencil.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (6) | No (0)
, London
Skin Tone | medium-tanSkin Type | normal-dryShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
Great

Great natural look best eyebrow pencil I've used perfect shade I'm medium tan

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (5) | No (1)
, Boston, Massachusetts
Skin Tone | lightSkin Type | normal-dryShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
Best eyebrow pencil I've tried

The gel in this pencil makes it glide on easily, look super natural, and totally stay put. A definite winner in the eyebrow department.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (8) | No (0)
, Frisco, TX
Skin Tone | lightSkin Type | normal-oilyShade | Pilsner - Medium Brown
Goes dull easily, but great look.

This pencil makes your eyebrows look naturally flawless. The only downside, I was confused if the stick was made of wood or plastic and could be sharpened. Turns out, it's wood and Milk is even coming out with their own sharpener soon! This is good because the tip goes dull very easily and is a little tricky to apply. But it makes you look cool!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Was this review helpful?   Yes (23) | No (0)
View More Reviews +

Tell us everything.

Overall Rating
0 / 350
Would you recommend this product to a friend?