Skip to content

Secret Santa Gifts That Won't Eat Your Entire Paycheck

 So good + affordable, you might grab some for yourself, too.

Models wear Milk Makeup products in a colorful holiday campaign Models wear Milk Makeup products in a colorful holiday campaign

The holiday season is finally here and—whether you celebrate Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, and/or Christmas—gift-giving is a major part of the experience. Secret Santa gift exchanges are a popular holiday tradition, and while they’re usually fun and affordable, let’s be honest: they’re not always easy to shop for. It can be challenging to figure out which Secret Santa gift ideas for coworkers will impress everyone.

Looking for tips on where to start? From holiday gifts on a budget to gifts for makeup lovers, keep scrolling for the best Secret Santa gift ideas to wow everybody on your list—all under $35!

Lip + Cheeks MVPs Gift Set

Whether you’re shopping for a beauty guru or a makeup novice, our Lip + Cheek MVPs Gift Set will be a welcome addition to their collection. The limited-edition gift includes two of our best-selling, full-size cream blush and lip colors in universally flattering shades. We’ve got two versions of the set: Vol. 1 includes Werk, our best-selling dusty rose hue and Smirk, its shimmery sister. Vol. 2 combines Rally, our mauve shimmer that went viral on social media, and Quirk, a spiced rose color. With just one swipe of these creamy confections, they’ll instantly look polished. And they’ll have you to thank.   

Lip + Cheek MVPs Vol. 1 box against a white background

Vegan Milk Moisturizer

#Skincareislife, so anyone would be thrilled to unwrap this Vegan Milk Moisturizer. With such nourishing ingredients as shea butter, jojoba, and aloe vera, it deeply hydrates the skin while keeping it moisturized for the long haul. Even better, the proprietary vegan milk blend is calming and comforting—perfect for prepping skin for a long day of work or unwinding before a full night’s rest. Gift it to your colleague with the 8-step regimen or your coworker who simply washes, moisturizes, and heads out the door. Either way, it’ll be the highlight of their skincare routine.  

Jar of Milk Makeup Vegan Milk Moisturizer on a white background

Infinity Long Wear Eyeliner

If your co-worker endlessly scrolls TikTok for new beauty looks to try; draws on their own skeleton makeup for Halloween; and never steps out without a perfect winged liner, this is the one product that will impress them. Infinity Long Wear Eyeliner is creamy, easy to apply, and lasts up to 12 hours without so much as a smudge. Available in black, brown, and navy blue, it comes equipped with a built-in sharpener and a soft blender tip that ensures it goes on smooth — what’s not to love? 

Product shot of Milk Makeup Infinity Long Wear Eyeliner on a white background

The Travel Stash

Out of all our Secret Santa gift ideas, this option is best suited for the jet-setter on your list. The Travel Stash is the perfect set for anyone who racks up frequent flier miles, from your co-worker who’s always on a business trip to your colleague who takes full advantage of their PTO. It includes everything they’ll need for an on-the-go beauty look: TSA-approved sizes of our Pore Eclipse Mattifying Primer, KUSH Mascara, and Lip + Cheek in Werk. That means, no matter where they’re headed, their skincare, lash, and makeup needs are covered.
Product shot of Milk Makeup The Travel Stash box on a white background

Bionic Bronzer

For the makeup lover who has glowing skin year round, Bionic Bronzer is the perfect gift for anyone on a budget. It creates a sunkissed glow that looks like you spent a week luxuriating on an island vacation—even in the middle of the winter. What’s more, the weightless formula is actually full of skincare benefits; it’s packed with nourishing ingredients like hyaluronic acid, mushroom extracts, and vegan collagen your skin will love.

Product shot of Milk Makeup Bionic Bronzer on a white background

KUSH Clear Brow Gel

We all know that person who spends more time on their brows than the hair on their head. Keep their eyebrows in a constant state of slayage with KUSH Clear Brow Gel. While the invisible gel formula holds brows in place all day long, the combination of hemp seed oil and aloe and cucumber extract keeps them nourished and looking healthy. Best part, it doesn't flake up and it'll leave their brows soft and flexible. Stiff where?

roduct shot of Milk Makeup KUSH Brow Lamination Gel on a white background

Holographic Stick Cream Prismatic Highlighter

If you really want to knock it out the park with your Secret Santa gift, grab the one item no makeup enthusiast can resist: a prismatic highlighter. Our Holographic Stick isn't just for any beauty lover; this is for your friend who plans their makeup look first then just finds an outfit to go with it. This highlighter creates a shimmering glow that demands a second—and third—look. For use on the cheeks, lips, and even eyes, it contains mango butter, coconut oil, and avocado oil for a hydrating, dewy finish.  

Product shot of Milk Makeup Holographic Stick on a white background
{"

Catherine Gaines is a prolific beauty and travel writer with a penchant for adventure and a taste for luxury. With bylines in Hello Beautiful, Madame Noire, Cassius Life, Slick Deals, and more, Gaines uses her platform to promote clean beauty, ethical travel, and BIPOC-owned brands across industries.

\n", "markdown"=>"**Catherine Gaines** is a prolific beauty and travel writer with a penchant for adventure and a taste for luxury. With bylines in Hello Beautiful, Madame Noire, Cassius Life, Slick Deals, and more, Gaines uses her platform to promote clean beauty, ethical travel, and BIPOC-owned brands across industries."}">

Catherine Gaines is a prolific beauty and travel writer with a penchant for adventure and a taste for luxury. With bylines in Hello Beautiful, Madame Noire, Cassius Life, Slick Deals, and more, Gaines uses her platform to promote clean beauty, ethical travel, and BIPOC-owned brands across industries.

All information is created for informational purposes only and is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.